"Punches and Prime Time: Brawl on Armenia’s Public Broadcaster Becomes a Study in Political Polarisation" by Carlo Coppola


This article titled "Una rissa in prima serata nella TV di Stato armena e il teatro della polarizzazione" by Carlo Coppola appeared in "In Città Giovinazzo", a newspaper directed by prof. Antonio Calisi, at the following link:


A televised political debate on Armenia’s public broadcaster ended in a fistfight this weekend, and the broadcaster chose to air all of it. Several international outlets described the episode of Mets Banavetch (Մեծ բանավեճ, “The Great Debate”), the flagship programme of 1TV, as a brawl “live on air”. It was not live. The episode was recorded on Friday, 13 November, and broadcast uncut on Sunday, 15 November.

The clash was between Boris Murazi, a journalist, editor of Politik.am and founder of the Sinjar National Yazidi Union, and Harutyun Mkrtchyan, an analyst and former member of former president Serzh Sargsyan’s Republican Party of Armenia. According to the outlet Hetq, Murazi appeared sixteenth on the electoral list of the “Armenia” alliance led by another former president, Robert Kocharyan. Mkrtchyan, for his part, has in recent years moved closer to the positions of Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan’s government. The programme was hosted by Tatev Danielyan and Petros Ghazaryan, the face of 1TV’s political coverage since December 2018. Italian commentators sometimes call Ghazaryan “the Armenian Bruno Vespa”, after the veteran presenter of Italy’s state broadcaster. His critics nickname him “Propaganda Petros” and accuse him of aligning too closely with the government’s narrative.

The exchange turned when Mkrtchyan pressed Murazi over an alleged “personal relationship” with Sargsyan. Insults followed, soon extending to relatives, to the point that bleeps were needed to mask them in the broadcast. After calling his opponent “ara”, an Armenian epithet, Murazi left his podium, crossed the studio and punched Mkrtchyan. A short scuffle ensued before security staff and others in the studio separated the two men. Murazi later defended the act in a Facebook live stream, calling it an “educational lesson”.

Ghazaryan’s reaction has drawn as much attention as the fight itself. Moments after the two men were pulled apart, he told the cameras the production would not cut the footage, and dismissed the incident with a shrug: “So what?”

Armenia’s Television and Radio Commission has since issued a statement condemning the guests’ conduct and the public broadcaster’s own responsibility. It argues that airing physical violence and obscenities in a pre-recorded programme breaches public-service standards.

The episode has also taken an uglier turn online. A wave of abusive comments has targeted Murazi because of his Yazidi background. The Sinjar NGO, which he founded and leads, has denounced the attacks as discriminatory and warned that any legal action against him seen as unjustified would be read as state endorsement of ethnic discrimination.

The affair has reached the Armenian diaspora as well. Several associations abroad are reportedly weighing legal action to seek damages for reputational harm from those involved in the brawl. Coming only days after clashes in the Armenian Parliament, the scene has further tarnished the image of Armenian institutions and organisations around the world.